The small town horror space keeps producing fresh voices and long-running favorites. This list rounds up 100 of the best, including Radio Rental, The Magnus Archives, and Relatos de la Noche.
20 of these 100 shows were named by an AI assistant (ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity or Gemini) when we asked about Small Town Horror.
Radio Rental
Discover real-life horror stories, from bizarre crimes to paranormal activity. These true stories are set inside the fictional world of Radio Renta...
The Magnus Archives
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
“Make your statement, face your fear.” The Magnus Archives is an award winning weekly horror fiction audiodrama podcast examining what lurks in the...
Relatos de la Noche
En la tradición de los clásicos de la radio, aquí se cuentan las historias, relatos y leyendas que habitan las calles de México e Iberoamérica.
Small Town Murder
Two comedians look at a small town, what makes it tick, and a murder that took place there. In depth research, horrible tragedy, and the hosts' com...
The NoSleep Podcast
The NoSleep Podcast is a multi-award winning anthology series of original horror stories, with rich atmospheric music to enhance the frightening ta...
CreepCast
Wendigoon and MeatCanyon share the scary, occult, and...creepy stories from around the internet.
Up and Vanished
Host Payne Lindsey heads to the edge of the arctic circle to investigate two mysterious disappearances from Nome, Alaska. Up and Vanished investiga...
Over My Dead Body
A Hollywood stuntwoman turned personal injury attorney. A handsome disbarred lawyer with a dark past. And an elaborate scheme that leads to murder....
Small Town Dicks
Small Town Dicks takes you behind the scenes of small town crime cases with the real detectives who investigated them. Hosts Yeardley Smith, twin d...
Lore
The award-winning podcast (also a TV show & book series) about dark historical tales. Each episode explores the mysterious creatures, tragic events...
Welcome to Night Vale
Named by ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 18, 2026
Twice-monthly community updates for the small desert town of Night Vale, where every conspiracy theory is true. Turn on your radio and hide. Never ...
Midnight Burger
When Gloria took a waitressing job at a diner outside of Phoenix, she didn't realize she was now an employee of Midnight Burger, a time-traveling, ...
Creepy
From creator Jon Grilz, a collection of the most famous and disturbing creepypastas and urban legends in the world. Listener discretion is advised....
Spooked
Spooked features true-life supernatural stories, told firsthand by people who can barely believe it happened themselves. Be afraid. Created in the ...
Unexplained
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
Unexplained is a haunting and unsettling bi-weekly podcast about strange and mysterious real life events that continue to evade explanation. A stor...
Old Gods of Appalachia
Named by ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
In the mountains of central Appalachia, blood runs as deep as these hollers and just as dark. Since before our kind knew these hills, hearts of unk...
Knifepoint Horror
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
Tales of supernatural suspense written, produced, and narrated by Soren Narnia. The text of these stories is licensed under Creative Commons Attrib...
Terrores Nocturnos
Historias de terror, misterio, casos reales, hechos inexplicables... Cada martes te traemos una nueva historia que no te dejará dormir y cada domin...
The Mysteries Of Derlin County
Brandon returns home to Derlin county to solve a mystery surrounding a girl who went missing from his high school. After figuring it out, he soon r...
Content:
Small Town Horror
The Void
What do you know about the dark? When you look into the shadows, do you feel them watching back? In the town of Milton, the darkness isn't just in ...
The White Vault
Explore the far reaches of the world’s horrors in the audio drama podcast The White Vault. Follow the collected records of a repair team sent to Ou...
Don't Mind
An anthology mystery series by Fool & Scholar Productions. Distributed by SpectreVision Radio. --------- Cruxmont: After his brother, Colin, goes m...
Content:
Small Town Horror
Nightmare Next Door
Nightmare Next Door is a true crime show that peels back the peaceful facade of small town America and exposes the dark secrets hidden behind its w...
S-Town
S-Town is a podcast hosted by Brian Reed from Serial Productions, a New York Times company. The story follows a man named John who despises his Ala...
How i Died
Bodies are piling up in the strange town of Springfield, and forensic pathologist Jonathan Spacer intends to find out why. But, Jon isn’t without h...
Alice Isn't Dead
Named by Gemini when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 15, 2026
A truck driver searches across America for the wife she had long assumed was dead. In the course of her search, she will encounter not-quite-human ...
The Lovecraft Investigations
Julian Simpson's mystery thriller/horror fiction series, based on several works by H.P. Lovecraft and his Cthulhu Mythos.
Something Scary
Something Scary is a horror podcast that brings listeners ghost stories, urban legends, and folktales from around the world. Hosted by Blair Bathor...
Mayfair Watchers Society
Trevor Henderson's creatures come to life in "Mayfair Watcher's Society." The town of Mayfair is just like any other: tidy lawns and book clubs, ba...
Content:
Small Town Horror
Wrong Station
Wrong Station is an award-winning podcast anthology of original horror and weird fiction. Drawing on the tradition of The Twilight Zone and the cla...
The Black Tapes
The Black Tapes is a weekly podcast from the creators of Pacific Northwest Stories, and is hosted by Alex Reagan. The Black Tapes Podcast is a seri...
Limetown
Named by Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
Ten years ago, over three hundred men, women and children disappeared from a small town in Tennessee, never to be heard from again. In this podcast...
Archive 81
Archive 81 is a fiction podcast about horror, cities, and the subconscious. New episodes will be released every other Wednesday. Start from "01 - A...
TANIS
Tanis is a bi-weekly podcast from the Public Radio Alliance, and is hosted by Nic Silver. Tanis is a serialized docudrama about a fascinating and s...
Borrasca
Named by Gemini when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 15, 2026
A gripping psychological thriller starring Cole Sprouse as Sam Walker. In the first season we followed Sam as he painstakingly recounts the summer ...
Thirteen
Feature length, atmospheric, spooky stories, explore an eerie universe of supernatural and occult tales. Stories that will make you laugh, make you...
The Left Right Game
Tessa Thompson stars as an idealistic young journalist trying to make a name for herself by following a group of paranormal explorers, obsessed wit...
Scary Story Podcast
Scary Story Podcast features scary stories about darkness, unexplained phenomena, ghosts, and the paranormal. A collection of short original horror...
Within the Wires
An immersive fiction podcast told through found audio from an alternate universe. Each season is a standalone story set in the same world. Written ...
The Silt Verses
In this horror/fantasy serial drama, Carpenter and Faulkner, two worshippers of an outlawed god, travel up the length of their deity’s great black ...
Hometown Ghost Stories
Hometown Ghost Stories dives into the history of haunted locations and investigates why and how these places earned their terrifying reputation. Ro...
Shelterwood
Shelterwood: A Suburban Gothic is a Docu-Horror Podcast written and produced by Stephen Indrisano. Join one man’s quest to find his long-lost siste...
Historias De Terror
Adéntrate en las sombras con "Historias De Terror", donde historias escalofriantes y misterios siniestros cobran vida. Desde encuentros fantasmales...
Video Palace
When video collector Mark Cambria watches a mysterious VHS tape, he begins talking in his sleep in a language that doesn't exist. Mark and his girl...
Havoc Town
A strange plague has struck Abbesstown, NH, a sleepy farming village in the foothills of the White Mountain: Fever, the vomiting of blood, wild nig...
Unwell, a Midwestern Gothic Mystery
Named by Gemini when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 15, 2026
Unwell, a Midwestern Gothic Mystery is a new audio drama from HartLife NFP.Lillian Harper moves to the small town of Mt. Absalom, Ohio, to care for...
The Sheridan Tapes
Named by ChatGPT when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 17, 2026
In 2018, famed horror writer Anna Sheridan disappeared, leaving behind only a box of mysterious cassette tapes. Detective Sam Bailey is tasked with...
Rabbits
When Carly Parker's friend Yumiko goes missing under very mysterious circumstances, Carly's search for her friend leads her headfirst into a ancien...
Pretending to be People
Pretending to be People is a mystery/horror role-playing podcast. Join Zach, Thomas, Luke, and Joe as they navigate a terrifying campaign filled wi...
Bridgewater
Named by ChatGPT and Perplexity when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
When a relic from his past is rediscovered, folklore professor Jeremy Bradshaw puts his life on hold to solve the mystery. Along the way, he’s help...
Death by Dying
Named by Gemini when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 15, 2026
The Obituary Writer of Crestfall, Idaho finds himself deeply in over his head as he investigates a series of strange and mysterious deaths… when he...
Hello From The Hallowoods
Come walk between the black pines! In this award-winning queer horror podcast, a cosmic narrator follows the increasingly connected residents of th...
I Am In Eskew
Trapped in the horror-filled and impossible city of Eskew, a man makes endless recordings of his day-to-day experiences, hoping to reach the outsid...
Terror en la Oscuridad
Sumérgete en Terror en la Oscuridad, donde cada video es una puerta a experiencias reales de terror. Descubre historias escalofriantes vividas por ...
Content:
Small Town Horror
King Falls AM
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
King Falls AM centers on a lonely little mountain town's late-night AM talk radio show and its paranormal, peculiar happenings and inhabitants. New...
End of the Loop
Named by Claude when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 18, 2026
Ethan escaped a time loop. He has no idea how.Mentally decades older and haunted by the things he did to survive, freedom means returning to the sa...
Content:
Small Town Horror
13 Days of Halloween
Season Four: Penance Without warning, Sayuri has been locked up in the Pendleton Rehabilitation Center, and no one is willing or able to tell her w...
The Call of the Void
In the bustling streets of New Orleans, a tour guide and a palm-reading outcast team up to unravel the mystery behind cases of sudden insanity bese...
Consumed
Named by Claude when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 18, 2026
When struggling journalist Sarah Simmons finds herself stranded in an idyllic New Hampshire town, her unexpected visit turns into a nightmare. Stee...
Content:
Small Town Horror
Dark Woods
From Legendary Producer Dick Wolf and Wolf Entertainment comes a new fiction series starring Corey Stoll (House of Cards, Ant-Man), Monica Raymund ...
Weird in the Wade
Do you like your spooky stories with some historical context? Do you like your history with a pinch of the paranormal? Then Weird in the Wade is th...
Uncanny County
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
Mystical truck drivers. Robots gone haywire. Killer clown demons. And pie. So. Much. Pie. This quirky, darkly comic, Southwestern-flavored antholog...
The Town Whispers
The Town Whispers is a narrative horror podcast, that will tell the many stories hidden behind the fog and the trees and the rain of a town called ...
What Happened in Skinner
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
Winner of the 2025 Ambie® for Best Indie Podcast, What Happened in Skinner traces a viral Internet mystery to the remote island of Skinner, Oregon–...
Sobrenatural Podcast
¿Tienes alguna una experiencia Paranormal? ¿Alguna vez viviste algo que todavía no puedes explicar? ¡Envíala y podría formar parte de un próximo ep...
Weeping Cedars
Named by ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
A slow burn horror story in the town of Weeping Cedars. Learn about both the past and present of Weeping Cedars with Documentary episodes from the ...
Ghosts In The Burbs
A cozy collection of (fictional?) stories. Here you'll find a lot of ghosts, a handful of demons, some monsters and an increasing amount of mysteri...
Wayward Guide For The Untrained Eye
Wayward Guide is a fictional investigative podcast about the sordid world of local politics, backroom dealings, and werewolves. When an alluring co...
Content:
Small Town Horror
Small Town Horror
Named by Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 20, 2026
Ryan Jennings ran from the horrors of Crayton 18 years ago. Now is is coming back to face his greatest fears and search for answers. Hosted on Acas...
Another F***ing Horror Podcast
Looking for a true crime and paranormal podcast that isn’t murder to get through? Check out “Another F*cking Horror Podcast.” Each week, bffs Moniq...
Ghost Town (No ads)
An archaeologist retires to teach high school, but when his students tell him about a nearby abandoned town, they set out to investigate. There the...
The Milbrook Files
These files were not meant to be found. The Millbrook Files is an investigative horror podcast following independent podcaster Avery Quinn as she s...
Content:
Small Town Horror
Nowhere, On Air
Semi-late night community radio broadcasts from a strange little town in the Crowsnest Pass, Alberta (aka, not just the middle of nowhere, but nowh...
Content:
Small Town Horror
The Other Side
The Charity Freelancer's Podcast | Where Charity Experience meets Freelance Success The Other Side: The Charity Freelancer's Podcast explores ...
the Dead Letter Office of Somewhere, Ohio
A series of weird horror podcasts set in the midwest. The Dead Letter Office of Somewhere, Ohio is a horror-comedy fiction podcast set within one o...
Content:
Small Town Horror
Ethics Town
Ethics Town is a cosmic horror podcast about philosophical conundrums in a weird small town! We're not going to answer the big questions for you, b...
Content:
Small Town Horror
Olive Hill
In 2001 two girls, on opposite sides of town, in the dead of night, stopped what they were doing and walked into the Daniel Boone National Forest. ...
Content:
Small Town Horror
Palimpsest
Palimpsest is a (mostly) single-voiced audio drama about memory, identity, and the things that haunt us. Each ten-episode season is a unique and se...
Spirit Box Radio
A fortnightly horror audio drama. Spirit Box Radio is a cosy horror fiction podcast about a radio show for enthusiasts of all things arcane. The sh...
Echoes under Ashwood
Echoes Under Ashwood is a cinematic cosmic horror podcast about memory, friendship, and the quiet dread of returning home.When a group of Gen-X fri...
Content:
Small Town Horror
NIGHTLIGHT: A Horror Fiction Podcast
Multi-award winning horror podcast featuring creepy stories with full audio production written by Black writers and performed by Black actors. So s...
The Occurrence in River Oaks
Named by Gemini when we asked about Small Town Horror · checked Nov 15, 2026
The Occurrence in River Oaks is an all new, entirely voice acted sci-fi horror audio drama from writer/director Nikki Durbin and Rogue Luna Enterta...
Content:
Small Town Horror
The Wicked Library
The Wicked Library is a Parsec Award winning show featuring horror fiction stories from upcoming, new, independent and bestselling authors. Our Tal...
Treat
Welcome to Treat, a podcast movie, from C13Features. In Treat, we quickly discover that a perfect town comes with a terrifying price. Starring Kier...
When Angels Visit Armadillo
When Angels Visit Armadillo uncovers a mystery shrouded in conspiracy, tucked away behind the moss in the rural town of Armadillo, Florida. Through...
Content:
Small Town Horror
The Hometown Horrors Podcast
The Hometown Horrors Podcast is the campfire we all gather around to tell our scariest stories; the tales where the horror hits close to home.
Content:
Small Town Horror
The Elmwood Strain
The Elmwood Strain is a psychedelic horror podcast and limited audio drama series in eight parts, from writer Rachel Woolley. Biological horror wit...
Content:
Small Town Horror
Dark River - Spooky Stories of a Small Town
Original haunting short stories of the strange happenings in Dark River, a fictional mining town in Northern Ontario, Canada in the early 20th cent...
Content:
Small Town Horror
Cidiot
Learning to live and love life in the Hudson Valley. Hosted by Mat Zucker. Have you fantasized about living in the country? Curious what the transi...
No show with that name on this list.
How this list is built
Shows are selected from PodSEO topic associations and matched AI recommendations. They are ordered by their average PodSEO score over records dated since seven days ago, with ties ordered by show name. The score combines podcast-platform search visibility, editorial placements, and chart performance, with adjustments for Apple listing status. AI recommendations help identify candidates; their frequency does not determine the order. Each list includes up to 100 shows with an Apple Podcasts ID and updates when regenerated.