The supernatural fanfiction space keeps producing fresh voices and long-running favorites. This list rounds up 52 of the best, including The Magnus Archives, Old Gods of Appalachia, and The White Vault.

13 of these 52 shows were named by an AI assistant (ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity or Gemini) when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction.

  1. The Magnus Archives
    The Magnus Archives
    “Make your statement, face your fear.” The Magnus Archives is an award winning weekly horror fiction audiodrama podcast examining what lurks in the...
  2. Old Gods of Appalachia
    Old Gods of Appalachia
    In the mountains of central Appalachia, blood runs as deep as these hollers and just as dark. Since before our kind knew these hills, hearts of unk...
  3. The White Vault
    The White Vault
    Explore the far reaches of the world’s horrors in the audio drama podcast The White Vault. Follow the collected records of a repair team sent to Ou...
  4. The Black Tapes
    The Black Tapes
    The Black Tapes is a weekly podcast from the creators of Pacific Northwest Stories, and is hosted by Alex Reagan. The Black Tapes Podcast is a seri...
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  5. Ghostfacers: A Supernatural Rewatch
    Ghostfacers: A Supernatural Rewatch

    Named by Perplexity when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    Each week hosts Richard & Reid rewatch an episode of The CW’s Supernatural and discuss real-world monster lore. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/priv...
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
  6. Monster Of The Week: A Supernatural Podcast
    Monster Of The Week: A Supernatural Podcast

    Named by Perplexity when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    Monster of the Week is a creepy but necessary podcast covering each and every episode of the TV show Supernatural. We've got hunks, goofs, hunks, d...
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
  7. Denim-wrapped Nightmares, a Supernatural podcast
    Denim-wrapped Nightmares, a Supernatural podcast
    Supernatural Recaps, Lore, & Laughs 🥂Join SPN newcomers Berly and LA as they revisit the CW series episode by episode. From monster mythology a...
    Audience:
    Fan Community Podcasts
  8. Fangasm
    Fangasm

    Named by Gemini when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    Prepare to be titillated, pop culture fans, because Fangasm is here; exposing the masses to the most ridiculous fanfiction stories on the internet....
  9. AMP Audiobooks : Amplifying the Joy of Fanfiction
    AMP Audiobooks : Amplifying the Joy of Fanfiction
    Fanfiction Audiobooks Presented by AMP https://linktr.ee/ashlynpugh - Each Fic Link Posted Monday - Friday, except some Holidays
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  10. Demon Feed Audio
    Demon Feed Audio
    I make podfics/narrate fanfictions from Ao3. Mostly gay fanfiction, and 18+ Hope you enjoy! I'm on all the platforms under the same name, check the...
    Content:
    Lgbtqia RomanceSpn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  11. Making It Up As We Go
    Making It Up As We Go

    Named by Perplexity and Gemini when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    A collection of podfics (audiobooks for fan fiction) for Destiel readers, by a Destiel reader.
    Content:
    Lgbtqia RomanceSpn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
  12. Cold Open Stories
    Cold Open Stories
    Cold Open Stories is an online storytelling community and publishing platform that features original short fiction, immersive audio dramas, and a l...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
  13. The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
    The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
    Join two literary nerds and Supernatural devotees in rewatching and (over)analyzing the show from episode one. We've got work to do! (Spoilers for ...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
  14. Carrying Wayward: A Supernatural Podcast
    Carrying Wayward: A Supernatural Podcast
    Friends and co-hosts Drew Shulman and Marie Vigouroux explore TV show Supernatural. With a focus on character narrative, growth and relationships, ...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  15. Literarion [Podfic]
    Literarion [Podfic]
    A collection of (mostly) Good Omens podfics. All details, tags, and space for comments and kudos are on AO3: https://archiveofourown.org/users/Lite...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
  16. Fanatical Fics and Where to Find Them: A Harry Potter Fanfiction Podcast
    Fanatical Fics and Where to Find Them: A Harry Potter Fanfiction Podcast
    Fanatical Fics and Where to Find Them is a Harry Potter fanfiction podcast. Fanfiction fanatics, Sequoia Simone and Kim, read and react to some of ...
    Content:
    Fandom HistorySupernatural Fanfiction
  17. Where the Stars Fell
    Where the Stars Fell
    Dr. Edison Tucker is having a very weird life. Not being able to die tends to color things that way. Lucille Kensington is the literary scene’s big...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Audience:
  18. Supernatural: The Crossroads
    Supernatural: The Crossroads

    Named by Perplexity when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    Supernatural: The Crossroads is a fan radio show all about the hit television show 'Supernatural'.
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  19. Spirit Box Radio
    Spirit Box Radio
    A fortnightly horror audio drama. Spirit Box Radio is a cosy horror fiction podcast about a radio show for enthusiasts of all things arcane. The sh...
    Content:
  20. Talkin‘ Fanfic
    Talkin‘ Fanfic
    Fanfiction taken seriously. Seriously! We interview authors, talk at length and in-depth about fics, we discuss characters and ships and tropes. Th...
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionWincest AnalysisSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  21. Ride or Die Podcast
    Ride or Die Podcast
    Ride or Die is the result of a series of poor choices that's led to this: an episode-by-episode examination of Supernatural, hosted by Waldorph and...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  22. Season 14, Time For A Podcast
    Season 14, Time For A Podcast

    Named by Perplexity when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    An obsessive fan, a fanfiction author, and a first time viewer go through every episode of Supernatural.
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
  23. Ficta Inferno
    Ficta Inferno

    Named by Perplexity when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    Dramatic readings of terrible fanfictions/fiction from the internet
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  24. That Vampire Show
    That Vampire Show
    That Vampire Show follows Kat Wright, a high school senior who is obsessed with the hit TV show, “Bloodlines.” After winning a fan fict...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  25. Idling In The Impala | a ride through SPN fandom and fanfiction
    Idling In The Impala | a ride through SPN fandom and fanfiction

    Named by Perplexity when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    A podcast for lovers of the show Supernatural and the fanfiction Sam and Dean Winchester inspire. Buckle up as your hosts, Sandra and Kasey, interv...
  26. Fine Pairings
    Fine Pairings
    A podcast about fanfiction. If ever there were sommeliers for fanfic, it would be Grace and Claire. So pour yourself a drink, and get ready for the...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
  27. Mixtape Book Club
    Mixtape Book Club

    Named by ChatGPT and Gemini when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    Supernatural has inspired a huge number of fanworks, and Destiel is the most popular romantic pairing within the show’s works on archiveofourown.or...
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
  28. The Epic Love Story of Sam and Dean
    The Epic Love Story of Sam and Dean

    Named by ChatGPT when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    A Supernatural rewatch podcast looking at the show through Wincest colored glasses. That's right! We're going to be going through all 327 episodes ...
  29. Audio Fanfic Podcast
    Audio Fanfic Podcast
    Making fanfiction accessible through audio. Stories: 2-XF 1-Other every Monday Podcast Eps: Bi-weekly Thursdays Whether🎙or 📝 anyone can contribute.
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
  30. Femmes Reading Filth
    Femmes Reading Filth
    Join friends and co-hosts, Jess and Emily, as they talk about popular tropes found in smutty romance novels and fanfiction! Usually joined by a gue...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
  31. In Defense of Fandom
    In Defense of Fandom
    In Defense of Fandom explores the world of fandom, focusing on creativity, community, and collaboration. The show, pulling from interviews with cre...
    Content:
    Fandom HistorySpn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
  32. So You Think You Can Fanon
    So You Think You Can Fanon
    Join Jake,Matt, Sergio, K-Bert, Shaun and the rest of the crew as we delve into the weird and whacky world of fanfiction and literature to tell you...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
  33. Fic Clique
    Fic Clique
    Fic Clique is a podcast about fanfiction. Join friends Nic, Brenna and Reid as they discuss fandom, fic, and their love of all things fannish.
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
  34. Fun Fiction: A Fan Fiction Podcast
    Fun Fiction: A Fan Fiction Podcast
    Join Scottye Moore and Megan Danger on an adventure into the world of Fan Fiction! Each week, they discuss one of their favorite pieces of media an...
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  35. The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural Rewatch
    The Mystery Spotcast: A Supernatural Rewatch
    It’s been years since the CW’s Supernatural ended. So why is it still such a phenomenon, and why are its fans stuck in a superhell love/hate relati...
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionWincest AnalysisSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  36. The Fangirl Business: A Supernatural Podcast
    The Fangirl Business: A Supernatural Podcast
    This podcast ended officially in October of 2026. No further episodes will be produced. Join Dr. Chrisha Anderson and Catherine McKenna for fe...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  37. Slash & Burn: A Gross Journey Through Fanfiction
    Slash & Burn: A Gross Journey Through Fanfiction

    Named by Perplexity when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    Slash and Burn is a very explicit comedy podcast that reads and discusses fanfiction across various fandoms large and obscure. Kera is the expert w...
    Content:
    Fandom HistorySupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  38. Fangirlin': A Supernatural Podcast
    Fangirlin': A Supernatural Podcast

    Named by Perplexity when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    Fangirlin' is a Supernatural podcast where we review and rave about anything and everything Supernatural related. From fanfiction to fandom discour...
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  39. Salt & Burn This - A Supernatural Rewatch Podcast
    Salt & Burn This - A Supernatural Rewatch Podcast
    Two lady-fans of the show "Supernatural" reminisce about their friendship and do an episode-by-episode rewatch of the entire series, and don't take...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  40. Fangirls Anonymous
    Fangirls Anonymous
    An addiction to fan fiction. Fangirls Anonymous is a podcast that delves into the world of fandom and fan fiction. Hosted by M and Bea. Produced by...
    Content:
    Fandom HistorySupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  41. Angel Radio: 
A Fan Fiction Anthology
    Angel Radio: A Fan Fiction Anthology
    Angel Radio is a Fan Fiction Anthology Podcast specifically dedicated to the SPN Fandom. The internet is bursting at the seams with amazing writing...
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  42. The Feral Fandoms Podcast
    The Feral Fandoms Podcast
    Why do some stories explode into global fandoms while others fade away? What makes readers ship characters, obsess over merch, and turn books into ...
    Content:
    Fandom HistorySupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  43. The Fic List
    The Fic List
    It’s like a book club… but for fan-fiction; or, the podcast in which two nerds send each other fanfics to read, recap, and review. Join two fan-fic...
    Content:
    Fandom HistorySupernatural Fanfiction
  44. Queer As Fiction
    Queer As Fiction
    Queer As Fiction is a podcast where three adult women (Amanda Holland, Kirsten King & Ashly Perez) write their own fan fiction based on audienc...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  45. So Get This: A Supernatural Podcast
    So Get This: A Supernatural Podcast

    Named by Perplexity when we asked about Supernatural Fanfiction ·

    Join me on my journey of revisiting Supernatural one episode at a time.
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  46. XenoCast
    XenoCast
    Welcome to XenoCast – the most gripping fanfiction audio drama dedicated to the Alien universe. Step into a world where acid blood burns through st...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  47. ANGEL RADIO
    ANGEL RADIO
    The Black Moon is RISING! Did you know angels send us messages in the form of angel numbers, using the vibrational frequencies? O’Neal Wyche, Creat...
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  48. TH4NKS FOR PL4Y1NG
    TH4NKS FOR PL4Y1NG
    An audiobook of the fanfiction “TH4NKS FOR PL4Y1NG” by Sam Gabriel
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  49. Fic Fix Podcast
    Fic Fix Podcast
    Fic Fix is a conversation podcast where we, Kiana and Rychele, discuss and debate what we love and don’t about book recommendations we give each ot...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  50. Afictionados
    Afictionados
    Afictionados is a podcast about embracing and disgracing fan fiction! The hosts, Jacob “Wagtag” Wagoner (@jcwagoner) and Rich “The Dick” Stevens (@...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  51. All Fic'd Up
    All Fic'd Up
    In All Fic'd Up, two long-time fans and fanfic writers - Karen and Marsha - examine the tropes that readers love, look at fanfic and fandom history...
    Content:
    Supernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO
  52. Fanfiction Nation
    Fanfiction Nation
    Content:
    Spn FanfictionSupernatural Fanfiction
    Produce this podcast? Track its rankings free in PodSEO

No show with that name on this list.