The faith-based true crime space keeps producing fresh voices and long-running favorites. This list rounds up 46 of the best, including Dateline NBC, 48 Hours, and Conspiracy Theories, Cults, & Crimes.
19 of these 46 shows were named by an AI assistant (ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity or Gemini) when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the ...
48 Hours
“48 Hours” uncovers the narrative behind crime and justice cases that have left a lasting mark on society. Award-winning CBS News correspondents th...
Conspiracy Theories, Cults, & Crimes
Named by ChatGPT when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 13, 2026
Conspiracy Theories, Cults, and Crimes explores true stories of belief taken too far: murderous cults, criminal cover-ups, mass manipulation, and t...
Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 14, 2026
Jimmy Akin’s Mysterious World invites you to explore the weird, strange, and unexplained with Catholic apologist Jimmy Akin and co-host Domenico Be...
The Miracle Files
Named by Claude and Perplexity when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 15, 2026
Faith-based true stories with the same storytelling intensity as true crime podcasts, The Miracle Files explores miraculous, harrowing events and i...
Cultish
Named by Gemini when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 14, 2026
Enter the Kingdom of the Cults with Cultish; a program that explores the impact of the cults from a theological, sociological, and psychologicalper...
UNSHACKLED! Audio Dramas
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 14, 2026
Real people, real stories, stirring dramatic accounts of hopelessness…and the hope that changes everything. These are UNSHACKLED! Audio Dramas, wit...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Believable: The Coco Berthmann Story
Coco Berthmann became internet-famous by sharing her story of surviving sex trafficking as a young child growing up in Germany. She was sheltered a...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Deadly Faith
Named by ChatGPT when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 13, 2026
Deadly Faith is a true crime podcast that explores the world where religion and crime collide. The world in which some people take their religious ...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill
Named by Gemini when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 14, 2026
Hosted by Mike Cosper, this podcast takes you inside the story of Mars Hill Church in Seattle – from its founding as part of one of the largest chu...
The Cold-Case Christianity Podcast
The Cold-Case Christianity Podcast is hosted by J. Warner Wallace. J. Warner is a Dateline featured cold-case homicide detective, Senior Fellow at ...
Heaven's Gate
In 1997, thirty-nine people took their own lives in an apparent mass suicide. The events captivated the media and had people across the planet aski...
Devil and the Deep Blue Sea
They say the Devil’s in the details, but when conspiracies captivate our imaginations, we often overlook the real devils walking among us. From the...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Deliver Us From Ervil
In the 1940s, a group of Mormon dreamers started a town in the Mexican desert. But what began as a utopian vision quickly turned sour when the foun...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Sacred Scandal
SEASON 4: The Many Secrets of Marcial Maciel The Many Secrets of Marcial Maciel is a gripping investigative podcast uncovering the shocking life an...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Hard Times and True Crimes
Named by ChatGPT when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 13, 2026
Listen to two Southern, Christian women tell each other historical true crime stories.
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Crisis: Clergy Abuse in the Catholic Church
Named by ChatGPT when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 13, 2026
A series about the sexual abuse crisis in the Catholic Church: its origins, characters, causes, and reforms. Host Karna Lozoya interviews bishops, ...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Liberty Lost
In Evangelical homes across the United States, sex outside of marriage is a sin against God. So, when Abbi becomes pregnant at 16, her devout paren...
Word of God
At Multitudes Church we believe Jesus Christ died for your sins, simply because He loved you. If you “believe on Him”, repent and accept Him into y...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
The Gospel of Crime Podcast
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 14, 2026
If you love the King James Bible and "true crime" stories, crave honest debate rooted in Scripture, and enjoy hosts who feel like real people wrest...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Christian True-Crime Junkies!
Named by ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 15, 2026
Squeaky-clean true crime for Christians! Looking for a faith-based true crime show that gives you all the spine-tingling stories without any of the...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Carol Costello Presents: The God Hook
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 14, 2026
In Season Two of her true crime series, The God Hook, journalist Carol Costello investigates the complex case of the Ohio Craigslist Killings—and i...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
The Culture
Named by ChatGPT when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 13, 2026
The Culture is a weekly podcast that delivers a thought-provoking and edgy take on Hip-Hop culture and current events. Hosted by Jeff DeLaRosa and ...
The Truth About True Crime with Amanda Knox
In 1986, the body of affluent, beautiful, 18-year-old Jennifer Levin was found dead in Central Park. Her killer: Robert Chambers, a tall, handsome ...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Cops, Criminals, and Christ
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 14, 2026
"Cops, Criminals & Christ" is a podcast delving into the intertwining worlds of law enforcement, crime, and faith. With Dale Sutherland, a form...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
The Unlovely Truth
Named by ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 15, 2026
Exploring the intersection of faith and true crime.
Unresolved
Mysterious disappearances and strange deaths which have yet to be resolved.
Saints Preserve Us
Saints Preserve Us is an irreverent but informative show that chronicles the bizarre lives, often equally bizarre deaths, and posthumous mythologie...
True Believer: The Unsolved Murder of Elizabeth Mackintosh
Named by ChatGPT when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 13, 2026
Early on the morning of March 26, 1990, Elizabeth Mackintosh was murdered on the campus of Covenant Theological Seminary in Creve Coeur, Missouri. ...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Heinous beliefs
Named by ChatGPT when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 13, 2026
Heinous Beliefs is a true crime podcast exploring the dark intersection of belief and brutality. Each episode unpacks chilling cases of murder, gen...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Faith & Felonies
Faith & Felonies dives into the chilling intersection of crime & religion. From killers who claimed "God told me to do it" to cult leaders,...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Clean Crime
True crime podcast created by a mother and daughter duo that is appropriate for younger audiences. Follow us on IG: @Clean_Crime
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
For The Love of God - True Crime
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 14, 2026
For the Love of God explores real stories where religion and power intertwine — from modern true crime to historical atrocities committed in the na...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Leaving Eden
Leaving Eden is a personal, reflective 15 episode podcast about faith, doubt, and what happens when the beliefs that once gave life meaning begin t...
True Crimes In Biblical Times
As of lately, the True Crime genre has become an epidemic in our society. With that being said, have you ever thought: "Where is God in all of this...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Who Killed Jesus? A True Crime Podcast
“Who Killed Jesus?” The answer may seem simple, but crimes are not always what they appear! Join Pastors Caleb & Marshela for a six week true crime...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Holy Ghost Preacher Boy
Holy Ghost Preacher Boy is a storytelling podcast that journeys through the echoes of Pentecostal fire, childhood faith, and the slow unraveling of...
Crime and Prayers
Welcome to Crime and Prayers, where we delve into the darkest corners of true crime and seek justice for the forgotten. Each episode explores gripp...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Bible True Crime With Mr. Thereally
Named by Perplexity when we asked about Faith-Based True Crime · checked Nov 14, 2026
A true crime podcast examining the most gripping and interesting crime stories from the Bible.
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
True Crime and Jesus
Hi. My name is Dez and Im a 3rd yr Evangelist student who loves true crime and the bible. I am gonna give yall some true crime from the bible and O...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
Midwest Malice
My name is Maryl, and I’m the host of Midwest Malice, a faith-based podcast dedicated to exploring true crime cases throughout the Midwest, with a ...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
The Bloody Bible Podcast
The Bloody Bible podcast hosts, Caz and Em, deep dive into contemporary true crime cases to investigate biblical violence and explore why our fasci...
Content:
Faith-Based True Crime
No show with that name on this list.
How this list is built
Shows are selected from PodSEO topic associations and matched AI recommendations. They are ordered by their average PodSEO score over records dated since seven days ago, with ties ordered by show name. The score combines podcast-platform search visibility, editorial placements, and chart performance, with adjustments for Apple listing status. AI recommendations help identify candidates; their frequency does not determine the order. Each list includes up to 100 shows with an Apple Podcasts ID and updates when regenerated.